I have looked around for a complete list of all starting options for humans and elves and I cannot find one anywhere. Not on the Wiki and not on elvengems either. You would think they would be uploaded somewhere.
Anyway, the female elf with leafy hat is a starting choice and it is still available. I had to go into the game and look, but there are three pages of avatar choices and it is on the first page of images.
@AtaguS is that image of avatars from the app? Because on the browser, those images are not all on the same page together.