sam767
Well-Known Member
Sadly, the penultimate version was completely unambiguous. For some reason I backed off to a vague recommendation.
---
Recommend updating the spire rewards system to have fewer Spell Fragment spells in the High Halls and none in the Laboratory.
Replacement rewards are open as long as they are easy for the devs to implement..
- Some have suggested troops, but those only help those who fight.
- Coin and supply instants are neutral, but I already have more than I will ever use. My guess this is true of players who routinely go to the top. But that is a guess.
- I like mana and gum trees. I have a large moonstone footprint that produces 72.6K mana for me every collection. My FS was critically short scrolls until Moonstone came along. My junior members are producing our current shortage item: Dust.
- I also like time instants.
- Teleport spells are always good. I used 31 to prep for the recently completed FA.
- No new rewards types are considered. This makes whatever the final recommendation is very easy to implement.
Detailed recommendation (to get the conversation going - the only strong opinions I have is nothing new, and fewer SFs.):
High Halls:
R1C3 replace 1250 with gum tree
R2C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant (go from useless and annoying to slightly useful)
R2C3 replace 1250 with mana tree
R3C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant
R3C4 replace 2000 with 5H
R4C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant
R4C3 replace 1250 with mana tree
Laboratory:
Replace all 500 with 30 minute
Replace all 1000 with 1HR
Replace all 1250 with mana or gum tree
Replace all 2000 with 5H
---
Recommend updating the spire rewards system to have fewer Spell Fragment spells in the High Halls and none in the Laboratory.
Replacement rewards are open as long as they are easy for the devs to implement..
- Some have suggested troops, but those only help those who fight.
- Coin and supply instants are neutral, but I already have more than I will ever use. My guess this is true of players who routinely go to the top. But that is a guess.
- I like mana and gum trees. I have a large moonstone footprint that produces 72.6K mana for me every collection. My FS was critically short scrolls until Moonstone came along. My junior members are producing our current shortage item: Dust.
- I also like time instants.
- Teleport spells are always good. I used 31 to prep for the recently completed FA.
- No new rewards types are considered. This makes whatever the final recommendation is very easy to implement.
Detailed recommendation (to get the conversation going - the only strong opinions I have is nothing new, and fewer SFs.):
High Halls:
R1C3 replace 1250 with gum tree
R2C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant (go from useless and annoying to slightly useful)
R2C3 replace 1250 with mana tree
R3C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant
R3C4 replace 2000 with 5H
R4C1 replace 500 with 30 min time instant
R4C3 replace 1250 with mana tree
Laboratory:
Replace all 500 with 30 minute
Replace all 1000 with 1HR
Replace all 1250 with mana or gum tree
Replace all 2000 with 5H