DeletedUser5800
Guest
Does this sound right?
The GA is nearly 3x more square efficient than the MH at pop. while being comparable in other benefits but since you can't build 3 GA's the MH is worth having only when the GA cost to level exceeds 3x the cost of the MH based purely on pop. gain to Kp spent which would be a GA of level 15. Then you should alternate upgrading them until GA is maxed.
Using a random test city between Dwarves and Fairies I compared a Lv 10 of each.
Ignoring the pop. gain because they are both 6% (obviously the GA is better because it's smaller)
I concentrate here on only the Gold vs Production
The Golden Abyss gives 244 sq. worth of gold production and takes 9 sq.
The Mountain Halls gives 40 sq. worth of goods production and takes 24 sq.
If you spent the gold from the GA in the wholsaler you get just under 1 manufactories worth of goods which is comparable to MH production gains.
The GA is nearly 3x more square efficient than the MH at pop. while being comparable in other benefits but since you can't build 3 GA's the MH is worth having only when the GA cost to level exceeds 3x the cost of the MH based purely on pop. gain to Kp spent which would be a GA of level 15. Then you should alternate upgrading them until GA is maxed.
Using a random test city between Dwarves and Fairies I compared a Lv 10 of each.
Ignoring the pop. gain because they are both 6% (obviously the GA is better because it's smaller)
I concentrate here on only the Gold vs Production
The Golden Abyss gives 244 sq. worth of gold production and takes 9 sq.
The Mountain Halls gives 40 sq. worth of goods production and takes 24 sq.
If you spent the gold from the GA in the wholsaler you get just under 1 manufactories worth of goods which is comparable to MH production gains.
Mountain Halls
At lv 10 64% Goods Production
4x Lv 16 Planks 298d x 4 = 1,192d so 64% is 762d benifit
762/298 = 2.5 more factories
361 pop req. per x 2.5 = 902 pop. req.
10sq. x 2.5 = 25sq.
4x Lv 16 Silk 618d x 4 = 2,472d so 64% 1,582d benifit
1,582/618 = 2.5 more factories
919 pop req per x 2.5 = 2,297 pop. req.
20sq. x 2.5 = 50sq.
4x Lv 15 Gem 571d x 4 = 2,284d so 64% is 1,461d benifit
1,461/571 = 2.5 more factories
222 pop. req. per x 2.5 = 555 pop. req.
20sq. x 2.5 = 50sq.
3,754 peoples worth of production
Lv 16 Res. 440 pop at 8sq.
(3,754/440)x8 = 68sq.
3x Lv 16 WS that would support that production
45sq.
612 pop. req. x 3 = 1,836
4 more res. 32sq.
Cult req. for 3WS, 13 res. and 2.5 of each manufactory
291 per WS x 3 = 873
155 per res x = 2,015
Plank 152 x 2.5 = 380
Silk 472 x 2.5 = 1,180
Gem 509 x 2.5 = 1,272
Total 5,720
Temple of Holy Fire 2,400 at 25sq.
(5,720/2,400) x 25 = 60sq.
Total Squares for Equivalent Production = 280
Let's compare to max boost since this is non-boost numbers and divide by 7
280/7 = 40
Golden Abyss Gold Production
Lv 10 2%g 3hr
Lv 19 Main Hall 7.7mil.
154,000 x 8 = 1,232,000d
Lv.16 res. 1,680h x 24 = 40,320
1,232,000/40,320 = 30.5
30.5 res. x 8 sq. = 244sq.
At lv 10 64% Goods Production
4x Lv 16 Planks 298d x 4 = 1,192d so 64% is 762d benifit
762/298 = 2.5 more factories
361 pop req. per x 2.5 = 902 pop. req.
10sq. x 2.5 = 25sq.
4x Lv 16 Silk 618d x 4 = 2,472d so 64% 1,582d benifit
1,582/618 = 2.5 more factories
919 pop req per x 2.5 = 2,297 pop. req.
20sq. x 2.5 = 50sq.
4x Lv 15 Gem 571d x 4 = 2,284d so 64% is 1,461d benifit
1,461/571 = 2.5 more factories
222 pop. req. per x 2.5 = 555 pop. req.
20sq. x 2.5 = 50sq.
3,754 peoples worth of production
Lv 16 Res. 440 pop at 8sq.
(3,754/440)x8 = 68sq.
3x Lv 16 WS that would support that production
45sq.
612 pop. req. x 3 = 1,836
4 more res. 32sq.
Cult req. for 3WS, 13 res. and 2.5 of each manufactory
291 per WS x 3 = 873
155 per res x = 2,015
Plank 152 x 2.5 = 380
Silk 472 x 2.5 = 1,180
Gem 509 x 2.5 = 1,272
Total 5,720
Temple of Holy Fire 2,400 at 25sq.
(5,720/2,400) x 25 = 60sq.
Total Squares for Equivalent Production = 280
Let's compare to max boost since this is non-boost numbers and divide by 7
280/7 = 40
Golden Abyss Gold Production
Lv 10 2%g 3hr
Lv 19 Main Hall 7.7mil.
154,000 x 8 = 1,232,000d
Lv.16 res. 1,680h x 24 = 40,320
1,232,000/40,320 = 30.5
30.5 res. x 8 sq. = 244sq.