• Dear forum visitor,

    It looks as though you have not registered for a forum account, or are not signed in. In order to participate in current discussions or create new threads, you will need to register for a forum account by clicking on the link below.

    Click here to register for a forum account!

    If you already have a forum account, you can simply click on the 'Log in' button at the top right of your forum screen.

    Your Elvenar Team

How to Find a Friendly FS That Is What They Say They Are- Follow-up

ikr777

Member
Hi Everybody,
I just want to find a good, active group that is friendly, has some friendly chat, does well with tournie and trades a lot of KP so that I can continue to grow my AW's.
I think these are regular things to look for, but to be honest, when I contact some Fellowships they all tell me- oh yeah, we're friendly and chatty and we do lots of KP trading. I join and only to find out it's not so.
Am I doing this wrong? Is it me?
I mean, I want to join a FS so that I feel I am playing with others, not just to hear crickets. And I don't mean that people have to be on there 24/7, making 1000's of comments, but I don't know, maybe it is me.

Is there anyone out there?
 
Hi @ikr777! Welcome to the forum. You'll likely get lots of advice here, most of it good and some of it conflicting. :) Here is what has worked for me. (I don't know what your process has been, so apologies if this is nothing new!)

For me, I start out with Elven Stats. I would click on "Tournaments", then select the date. I suggest picking a week that has finished the tournament, so anything before this week.
  1. Start with the highest ranking FS, and make note of any that have less than 25 members, or that indicate in the name that they are recruiting.
  2. Keep going down the list until you have 10 or so Fellowships. You now have a list of some of the highest performing fellowships on your server.
  3. Now go in-game and check out the descriptions of each of the Fellowships. If they list expectations that I don't meet, remove them from the list. Or if the description doesn't match what I'm looking for, remove them from my list. Some say they are chatty or quiet, some want a certain city ranking or certain Spire performance, etc.
  4. If I don't have any Fellowships left on my list, then go back to Elven Stats and get the next group of ~10 or so and repeat.
  5. If a Fellowship gets past that "background check", then I contact them in-game and introduce myself, and let them know I'm looking for a new Fellowship.

Posting here on the forum can also help, but there are a lot of people in-game who are not on the forums, so I wouldn't _only_ post here.

I believe Discord has threads for "fellowships seeking members" and "members seeking fellowships", so if you are on Discord, that might be worth a shot too.

Good luck and have fun!
 
Hi @ikr777! Welcome to the forum. You'll likely get lots of advice here, most of it good and some of it conflicting. :) Here is what has worked for me. (I don't know what your process has been, so apologies if this is nothing new!)

For me, I start out with Elven Stats. I would click on "Tournaments", then select the date. I suggest picking a week that has finished the tournament, so anything before this week.
  1. Start with the highest ranking FS, and make note of any that have less than 25 members, or that indicate in the name that they are recruiting.
  2. Keep going down the list until you have 10 or so Fellowships. You now have a list of some of the highest performing fellowships on your server.
  3. Now go in-game and check out the descriptions of each of the Fellowships. If they list expectations that I don't meet, remove them from the list. Or if the description doesn't match what I'm looking for, remove them from my list. Some say they are chatty or quiet, some want a certain city ranking or certain Spire performance, etc.
  4. If I don't have any Fellowships left on my list, then go back to Elven Stats and get the next group of ~10 or so and repeat.
  5. If a Fellowship gets past that "background check", then I contact them in-game and introduce myself, and let them know I'm looking for a new Fellowship.

Posting here on the forum can also help, but there are a lot of people in-game who are not on the forums, so I wouldn't _only_ post here.

I believe Discord has threads for "fellowships seeking members" and "members seeking fellowships", so if you are on Discord, that might be worth a shot too.

Good luck and have fun!
Yes, thank you Grishnak.
That was my process, more or less, cross checking FS listings against Elvenstats and crossing off FS's that seemed a bit beyond what I could contribute to based on their description. I've tried a handful of FS's so far and each time I contacted the AM or whoever was listed as being the contact person and asked my questions. Are you a chatty? or at least mildly talkative group, do you have KP chains? etc. Each time the answer was- Oh yeah, we do all that! Come on in! Yay! . . .
The first one I joined I had a question about something and there was 3 or 4 comments on chat about it. The next thing someone came onto chat and said- woah, what's going on! The chat is blowing up! I've never seen so many comments on here! So, obviously there was never going to be a lot of conversing with that group.

Then there was another group that didn't chat, after I was told they were really chatty. Someone posted something on chat one day and then immediately came on and apologized for posting something. They meant it for a different chat.

Or FS's that don't believe in KP email trading chains for building AW's after it was something I asked if they do.

I'm just feeling somewhat defeated I guess. I mean, if I ask you what it's like at your FS, just tell me the truth, I can handle it. If I don't want what you're offering I'll just go away and you'll never have to hear from me again.

How do I find a FS that is what they say they are without having to try out every single last FS on the list?
 
Interesting problem, I don't have any solid suggestions. Hopefully some of the more experienced players will chime in.

I do recall seeing some (well, at least one) FS descriptions that mentioned having a dedicated Discord channel. I assumed they were more chatty than average. I'm not sure how common that is though.
 
Hi Everybody,
I just want to find a good, active group that is friendly, has some friendly chat, does well with tournie and trades a lot of KP so that I can continue to grow my AW's.
I think these are regular things to look for, but to be honest, when I contact some Fellowships they all tell me- oh yeah, we're friendly and chatty and we do lots of KP trading. I join and only to find out it's not so.
Am I doing this wrong? Is it me?
I mean, I want to join a FS so that I feel I am playing with others, not just to hear crickets. And I don't mean that people have to be on there 24/7, making 1000's of comments, but I don't know, maybe it is me.

Is there anyone out there?
Yeah, you are right. I have, in the past, joined forces with 20+ fellowships on Khelonaar to help fix that problem. We had a chart where we described our fs with the idea of moving players around, and sharing any players we found needing a home. We would then try to match them with a fellowship we thought they would like and fit into. I do believe it helped, but not as much as I'd like. I had to stop leading that group as I got pretty sick for a number of months. Am better now and thinking of restarting with some changes.

My recommendation is to "visit" rather than join. Tell the AM you are only there for a visit (most will let you in) and thus, if it isn't to your liking, you can move on without appearing to abandon anybody. It's one of the things our group did if we were unsure of the match.

AJ
 
Yeah, you are right. I have, in the past, joined forces with 20+ fellowships on Khelonaar to help fix that problem. We had a chart where we described our fs with the idea of moving players around, and sharing any players we found needing a home. We would then try to match them with a fellowship we thought they would like and fit into. I do believe it helped, but not as much as I'd like. I had to stop leading that group as I got pretty sick for a number of months. Am better now and thinking of restarting with some changes.

My recommendation is to "visit" rather than join. Tell the AM you are only there for a visit (most will let you in) and thus, if it isn't to your liking, you can move on without appearing to abandon anybody. It's one of the things our group did if we were unsure of the match.

AJ
Ajqtrz, that is a good idea. I will definitely bring that up with the next FS I approach
 
Just a follow-up
I have found a FS that I'm very happy to be part of. It's called The Knights of Good. They are a great and helpful group and we have fun.
It was a bit of a slog finding them, it's true. I did my research with Elvenstats and on the forum here and had a lot of dead-ends, but I stuck it out.
For anyone else that is having the same struggle finding a FS that fits, don't give up : )
 
Just a follow-up
I have found a FS that I'm very happy to be part of. It's called The Knights of Good. They are a great and helpful group and we have fun.
It was a bit of a slog finding them, it's true. I did my research with Elvenstats and on the forum here and had a lot of dead-ends, but I stuck it out.
For anyone else that is having the same struggle finding a FS that fits, don't give up : )
I used to be a mage in that fellowship, before I was invited to become assistant archmage at Thornwood (and a few months later became archmage), and you are right; they're a great group. When I was with them we had 3 first place finishes in the Fellowship Adventures. We went all out back then (in 2021, I think). Great group; may you be very happy there.
 
Back
Top