Every FS Member gets FSA Rewards

[DeletedUser9601]

Just drop the requirement that everyone contribute at least "1" badge to get the reward. Its silly for a number of reasons:
-that someone could contribute zero badges in round 1, and 500 badges in round 2 and 3 somehow gets fewer rewards than someone who gives 1 badge in rounds 1, 2 and 3.
-its stupid to slow down an FS that wants to let everyone have a chance to drop a badge.
-there's not an easy way to check who's contributed.
-I can't imagine any FS cares if a member doesn't contribute but still gets rewards (and if they do, kick out the non-helpers).

 

[Ashrem]

I agree. There will be some groups who don't agree. It might require the ability of the Archmage to override automatic participation

I'm not sure on Inno's reasons. At worst, if there is some concern about handing out a bunch of loot to inactive cities (which maybe haven't played in months), that could be gotten around via an "opt-in" that runs until the event is completed. First quest up could say do you wish to participate in the event, or decline to participate? That would also allow a filter to remove the quest givers, which would satisfy some people who don't want to see the FA at all.

 

[Enevhar Aldarion]

No, there are enough lazy people in the game who barely do anything and should be kicked from fellowships because of it.

What Inno needs to do is keep one path always needing goods, like this one. Then anyone who is actually paying attention, and wants the rewards, can throw in a few marble or whatever and get the prize.

And people who say they refuse to do the adventures, for whatever reason, do not deserve a free reward.

And if a fellowship wants to power through the stages so quickly that some players do not even have a chance to log in and add something, then those fellowships need a better plan of their own to make sure anyone who wants to participate gets a chance to.