Ancient Wonder research full notification

[Ashrem]

The functionality is there somehow because we get popups for OTHER people's AW being completed but not our own.

I think we'd find if we could see the code that we're not really being notified Research is complete, rather we are being notified that something was added to our inventory becuase research complete. people who contributed but don't get anything don't get a notification, and we don't get anything either.

I suspect a really easy way for developers to fix this is not to add another notification, but to add a 3kp instant to anyone who's AW finishes research.

 

[Ashrem]

Cleanup the grammar and opened the vote.

I voted yes, and thanks, but I also think it might be premature to vote. The discussion is still active, and I feel like we might have come up wtih a better/more-complete idea to submit with a better chance of success. i guess we can always try again if this one doesn't get anywhere.

 

[Enevhar Aldarion]

I understood it as 'considering the current way AW completions popup at log in it would only be...'

He used the term "log-in", which in that context, to me, meant not until your next log-in, no exceptions.

 

[Dreamyn2]

I would vote yes unless it means every time I open a city I get a notice “your AW is complete and ready to upgrade “, excepting if one was completed between visits.

 

[StarLoad]

Your comment said they only pop up when you log in.

Fine even, if it was only after a login, it would be fine the idea is NOTIFICATION that it is done not whether I spelled out over possible permutation of the event. My comment was any notification would be great and the when doesn't really matter does it?

Really Enevher sometimes it seems all you want to do is nitpick on a single word, maybe that should be your title? This seems like an easy and simple QoL feature that can be done, so lets do it and I cant see any reason why one would not want to know one time.

Ed

 

[Ashrem]

Really Enevher sometimes it seems all you want to do is nitpick on a single word,

When we're trying to get the devs to change something, every word matters. It's easy for someone else, especially a developer who's firt language might not be the same, to not udnerstand what we want and give us something which isn't it.

 

[StarLoad]

When we're trying to get the devs to change something, every word matters. It's easy for someone else, especially a developer who's firt language might not be the same, to not udnerstand what we want and give us something which isn't it.

Sure if I was the OP and not just answering someone else's comment. Only the OP post is presented to the CM's for a vote, as Helya had explained

Ed

 

[defiantoneks]

i have added a secondary edit with clarification on HOW the notification would be handled

 

[Dreamyn2]

@defiantoneks thank you

 

[Enevhar Aldarion]

i have added a secondary edit with clarification on HOW the notification would be handled

That works for me. And it removes the confusion that comments by others may have generated.

 

[Ashrem]

Sure if I was the OP and not just answering someone else's comment. Only the OP post is presented to the CM's for a vote, as Helya had explained

Ed

He indicated where the other person's idea doesn't match the OP's post which means it doesn't accurately represent the idea we voted for.

i have added a secondary edit with clarification on HOW the notification would be handled

That might be a mistake. According to the rules that breaks the poll onece voting commences, discussion can continue "However: No alterations can be made to the idea as it's stated in the opening post". This particular change doesn't bother me, but changing anything after people have voted is not usually acceptable anywhere.

 

[Deleted User - 849777001]

Would it show up on our AW page...like the "contributed" notification shows up on recipients AWs now?

I play on the App and that little "contributed" notification sure helps me keep track of my shared runes, altho I probably should keep a running list (just to help me avoid mistakes,, and keep me honest).

 

[Momonar]

While they are at it, can they make the donation history to the wonder available to the player (or the fellowship AM).
Those of us who run Wonder Societies would really love that feature.

 

[Deleted User - 593524]

Voted yes. Great idea

 

[defiantoneks]

That might be a mistake. According to the rules that breaks the poll onece voting commences, discussion can continue "However: No alterations can be made to the idea as it's stated in the opening post". This particular change doesn't bother me, but changing anything after people have voted is not usually acceptable anywhere.

well they kept shouting that it wasnt clear enough. you cant win around here.

 

[Enevhar Aldarion]

well they kept shouting that it wasnt clear enough. you cant win around here.

You are okay. You did not change the main idea, only added options for how it could be implemented.

 

[Ashrem]

Hi @Astram this poll closed a week ago. Is there anything else that needs to be done before the tags are changed?

 

[Astram]

Not being considered as this was a previous suggestion for the same idea.