Well I've read your forum posts, and I've spoken at length with some of the players in question, and based off that I'm far more likely to believe their side.
Cooperative, not competitive. HUGE difference.
Oh, because it's soooo hard to track who has contributed(and will therefore get a prize)
You seem to think we are cracking a whip and force players to make X of Y badges, but it's far far simpler than that. All we do is track who has contributed so that no one misses out on a prize. That and if one player wants to focus on making all dwarven badges the rest of us know to focus on other things. It's actually pretty silly imo for everyone to just make random badges as you might get to a point where no one has made the required 1 day badges and you're out of time. A little communication and a third party tool for that communication goes a long way.
Being an AM and tracking stuff to help the FS run smoothly is quite easy if you aren't a terrible AM.