It is, and You're obviously a well-grounded person to take it so well. Perosnally, I think it's a steaming pile.
One thing I've learned is that if something new is coming along, it's really worth looking at what the busy forum participants think of it before putting it down anywhere. In particular, look for an analysis by
@SoggyShorts . If he doesn't think it's a good idea, it probably isn't. If you don't agree, ask him, because he'll give you a detailed mechanics breakdown and likely point out what you are missing before you waste the effort.