...I've never had the reflexes to begin with. *laughs* I don't like fancy controls at all or shooter games, although I did become halfway decent with the first Gears of War, probably because it was much easier to play than most of the genre, but I didn't really enjoy it, exactly. It was more stressful than fun. GIVE ME POINT AND CLICK, CURSED GAME DEVELOPERS.
Never let myself try WoW, much the same as I've never let myself try hard drugs. My lack of self-control being what it is, the latter would be the death of me, and the former would mean I wouldn't ever see daylight again.
Diablo (have you tried The Hell mod for it? AWESOME) and Diablo II are still two of my favorite games, but I skipped III out of sheer disgust at having to maintain an internet connection even while playing single-player. That's the way all games seem to be heading, and eventually I'll be left with nothing new to play. KHHHAAANNN!!!
Love Civilization, Heroes of Might and Magic, Fallout, Final Fantasy, Divinity, the games set in the Forgotten Realms and Torment, original Warcrafts and Starcraft, Torchlight, The Sims, very old games that won't run on Windows 7 that I have to use an emulator of Windows 3.1 in order to play out of nostalgia's sake, Dragon Age, the Elder Scrolls occasionally, and, uh, I know there's a lot more but that's all I can think of off the top of my head. Ah, some Zeldas, too.